Skip to content
Independent guides to US insurance, written from official sourcesInsurance toolsHow we make moneyHow we check what we publishGlossary
InsuranceZenithUS insurance, explained from official sources
Search
We don't sell insurance and rank no insurer. Pages that carry ads say so.How we make money

Fixed annuity vs. fixed index annuity

According to the NAIC Buyer's Guide for Deferred Annuities, a fixed indexed annuity is a type of fixed annuity that earns interest based on changes in a market index, while money in a fixed deferred annuity earns interest at a rate the insurer sets.

  • Official sources: 2
  • Updated Nov 19, 2026
  • Official publishers: 2
  • No verdict: facts side by side
InsuranceZenith Editorial TeamWritten from official sources, every sentence tied to its passage
Checked by automated passage checksand a review of each batch by separate AI assistants, not by human experts. Official sources and automated checks
Published by
Concerneo
Sources read
Page last updated

Fixed annuity

7 points compared
  • How interest is earnedMoney in a fixed deferred annuity earns interest at a rate the insurer sets.
  • What is guaranteedA fixed annuity guarantees at least a minimum interest rate, and only that minimum rate is guaranteed.
  • Growth potential (SEC)The SEC describes the growth of a fixed annuity as guaranteed growth at a fixed rate of interest.
  • Potential for loss (SEC)The SEC says the potential for loss in a fixed annuity is generally none, other than a surrender charge for withdrawals or surrenders taken during the surrender charge period. Separately, the SEC says the insurer may also adjust the value of an annuity through a Market Value Adjustment or an Interim Value Adjustment, and these contract adjustments are often negative and may significantly lower its value.

Fixed indexed annuity

7 points compared
  • How interest is earnedMoney in a fixed indexed annuity earns interest based on changes in an index.
  • What is guaranteedIn a fixed indexed annuity, the interest rate is guaranteed to never be less than zero, even if the market goes down.
  • Growth potential (SEC)The SEC says the growth potential of a fixed indexed annuity is tied to an index's performance, but with limits on how much you can earn.
  • Potential for loss (SEC)The SEC says the potential for loss in a fixed indexed annuity is generally none, other than a surrender charge for withdrawals or surrenders taken during the surrender charge period. Separately, the SEC says the insurer may also adjust the value of an annuity through a Market Value Adjustment or an Interim Value Adjustment, and these contract adjustments are often negative and may significantly lower its value.
Comparison: Fixed annuity and Fixed indexed annuityEach cell is tied to an official source listed at the end of the page.
Point comparedFixed annuityFixed indexed annuity
How interest is earnedMoney in a fixed deferred annuity earns interest at a rate the insurer sets.Money in a fixed indexed annuity earns interest based on changes in an index.
What is guaranteedA fixed annuity guarantees at least a minimum interest rate, and only that minimum rate is guaranteed.In a fixed indexed annuity, the interest rate is guaranteed to never be less than zero, even if the market goes down.
Growth potential (SEC)The SEC describes the growth of a fixed annuity as guaranteed growth at a fixed rate of interest.The SEC says the growth potential of a fixed indexed annuity is tied to an index's performance, but with limits on how much you can earn.
Potential for loss (SEC)The SEC says the potential for loss in a fixed annuity is generally none, other than a surrender charge for withdrawals or surrenders taken during the surrender charge period. Separately, the SEC says the insurer may also adjust the value of an annuity through a Market Value Adjustment or an Interim Value Adjustment, and these contract adjustments are often negative and may significantly lower its value.The SEC says the potential for loss in a fixed indexed annuity is generally none, other than a surrender charge for withdrawals or surrenders taken during the surrender charge period. Separately, the SEC says the insurer may also adjust the value of an annuity through a Market Value Adjustment or an Interim Value Adjustment, and these contract adjustments are often negative and may significantly lower its value.
Ongoing fees (SEC)In a fixed annuity, the SEC says ongoing fees are reflected in the interest rate.In a fixed indexed annuity, the SEC says ongoing fees are reflected in the limits on how much you can earn.
Relative risk (SEC)In the SEC's comparison table, a fixed annuity is described as the least risky, with the lowest potential return.In the same table, a fixed indexed annuity is described as riskier than a fixed annuity, but with more potential return.
Who regulates it (SEC)The SEC describes a fixed annuity as an insurance product regulated by the state insurance regulator.The SEC describes a fixed indexed annuity as an insurance product regulated by the state insurance regulator.

No verdict. We do not say which option to choose. The right one depends on your situation, your contracts and what an insurer offers you.

Advertisement

From this site

How we check every statement before it is published

Each statement is tied to a dated passage of an official source.

What this page does not cover

This page compares how the SEC and the NAIC describe these annuity types and does not compare insurance companies or rates. This page does not assess individual situations.

Sources

  1. Annuities, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (Investor.gov). Read November 18, 2026.An insurance product. Regulated by state insurance regulator. Contact the State insurance …
  2. Buyer's Guide for Deferred Annuities, National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). Read November 18, 2026.Fixed annuities guarantee your money will earn at least a minimum interest …

We cite a few words and link to the official text. Full copies are kept as internal records, not republished.

Every statement on this page is tied to an official source that we copied and dated. We do not sell insurance and we do not recommend companies. Editorial policy, Data sources.

We don't sell insurance and rank no insurer. How we make money